As best as you can remember, how did it work? When you clicked the button, what was the very next thing that happened -- what did you see?

I'll grab a screen shot of the comments and send to you Doc.

yes we need a reply button for comments for sure

I don't believe iComp did. MacJams did, though.

I'm not a huge fan of the reply for every comment. Maybe allow a reply comment every 5 or 10 comments? It just gets too busy for me...just my opinion :) I feel that replying to thank for a comment could be done via the email...It just feels a big too much.. :)

RubyDubidoux, I see your point! What about maybe just a like/heart kind of thing, like FB has?